Home » About Roofers » Roof Insurance Claims
30% of homes in Chicago are susceptible to storm damage due to weather-related events. With a good roof, a house is a home. In addition to comfort and safety, a roof affects the aesthetics and overall value of a property. However, homeowners are often faced with the need to make urgent decisions regarding roof insurance claims. Professional market players are familiar with this phenomenon and can manipulate it by withholding useful information. So keep two scenarios in mind to protect your interests – in the event of a natural disaster or storm damage and a scheduled repair.
Call Any Of Our Trusted Roofing Experts Today
Before filing an insurance claim for roofing, a thorough inspection and justification of the scope of work by assessing the extent of roof damage is necessary.
First, an independent visual inspection of the exterior condition of the roof takes place. Attention must be paid to mechanical damage — holes, cracks, or shifting shingles. The degree of wear and tear, weathered materials, crumbled granules on the roofing, and traces of leakage inside the house — stains on the ceiling or walls — must also be assessed.
Invite a certified inspector to officially document hail damage roof insurance and other scenarios for insurance estimates. Your agent will write a report with photos and repair recommendations about insurance roof leak claims, using professional equipment to detect hidden problems, such as moisture under the roof surface.
Insurance adjusters can bias homeowners’ claims, regardless of their promises in flyers about hail damage on a roof insurance claim.
Statistics on an organization’s completed claims can be obtained from the Illinois Department of Insurance, the state’s regulatory agency. Try to ask your insurance or study reports from the National Association of Insurance Commissioners (NAIC) with data on claims and endorsements. Reviews on sites like Yelp or the Better Business Bureau provide insight into an insurer’s reputation, especially after storm damage.
The «right» insurance agent may help you avoid pitfalls when filing every roof wind damage insurance claim. For example, it may be a recommendation to get a professional roof assessment before filing so that any damage to your roof or wear and tear is accounted for promptly.
An agent clarifies policy exclusions, such as roof age or materials, that may affect the cost of insurance, as well as coverage limits to avoid surprises when an insured event occurs.
Some roofing contractors may offer low prices for services, promising to do the work «on insurance», which looks tempting to homeowners.
In doing so, contractors hide the poor quality of excessively cheap materials, resulting in a short lifespan of the roof and quick leaks. Among other things, the homeowner may be charged a list of works that are not specified in the insurance policy or seriously puzzle the need to be completed.
Unscrupulous roofing companies may delay the process or disappear altogether, leaving the customer with substandard repairs and trouble.
If your roof wind damage insurance claim is approved, you must pay your deductible. It is the amount you must pay out of your pocket before the insurance company begins to cover the remainder of the cost. Size typically ranges from $500 to $2000, depending on the type of policy.
Contractors who promise to cover this amount are likely breaking the law. Such offers may be part of fraudulent schemes to defraud insurers and can lead to legal consequences. Read the terms of the contract carefully and check the contractor’s promises against insurance rules.
An insurance adjuster must approve a roof damage insurance claim for repair or replacement before the start of work with a contractor. Often, contractors offer to do this before the roofer’s insurance claim is approved. However, it is possible that the insurance company will only cover some of the costs, and the homeowner will have to pay out of pocket.
Contracting with a roofer after official information about the amount of coverage will protect you from surprises and irrational spending.
What to look for before signing a contract with a roofer:
Choosing experienced contractors and verifying the above information will protect you from scams and unforeseen situations.
When renovating, 40% of projects encounter additional costs not planned for in the insurance estimate. For example, there may be costs after approving your claim:
To avoid surprises, a roofing contractor can put together a more accurate and detailed estimate that includes all potential costs for quality workmanship.
More Than Roofs: It's About Your Home's Heart. Keeping your home safe and dry, no matter the weather
When a storm damages your roof, you must call a roofing contractor to inspect your roof. How can roof repair costs and policy terms affect coverage?
Minimum coverage is designed only for damage from basic risks, such as hail or wind. Extended coverage includes wear and tear, additional risks, and expensive materials.
Parameter | Repairs | Coverage | Recommendations |
Age of roof | The older, the higher the risk of damage | Older roofs may be partially covered or not covered | Provide documentation of regular maintenance |
Type of damage | Hail, wind, leaks – repair range from $5000 to $15000 | Damage from natural disasters is more likely to be covered | Specify the type of damage on the application and attach photos |
Material | Material (metal): $8–$12/sq ft. = $100 (average) Labor: $15–$20/sq ft. = $175 Total: $275 | Material (asphalt shingles): $3–$5/sq. ft. = $40 (average) Labor: $5–$10/sq. ft. = $75 Total: $115 | Metal is more expensive to repair than shingles or asphalt. Use material approved by the insurance company |
Policy limit | If the limit is below $10000, the policy may not cover the repair | Exceeding the limit leaves some of the cost to the owner | Verify that the reported cost of repairs does not exceed the policy limit |
Depreciation | Insurers take depreciation into account when calculating payouts | The payout may be less than the amount requested | If possible, request a calculation without taking depreciation into account |
Detail the application and the cause of the damage, and meet filing deadlines. In Chicago, it is common to limit filings of wind damage to roof insurance coverage after an incident to no more than 60 days.
The higher the deductible, the less money you will receive from the insurance company. For example, if the deductible is $2000 and the cost of repairs is $10000, the insurance company will only cover $8000. However, policies with a high deductible are less questioned by the insurance process because they reduce risk. For Chicago homes with a higher risk of damage to your roof (such as from hail or high winds), choose a deductible that you can cover in an emergency.
The type of insurance policy determines the amount of coverage you get for roof repairs. Two types of coverage are available for homeowners insurance – Replacement Cost Value (RCV) and Actual Cash Value (ACV).
Parameter | RCV | ACV |
Coverage size | The full cost of repairing or replacing the roof | Residual value, including depreciation |
Example calculation | The cost of a new roof is $10000. You will receive $10000 without a deductible | The cost of a new roof is $10000. Accounting for depreciation – $4000. Payout after deductible: $6000 |
Insurance premium | Above | Below |
Recommendations | For those who want maximum protection | For frugal owners who have a reserve for additional expenses |
If the roof of your home was damaged by hail and you have an RCV policy, the insurance company will pay for the entire roof replacement, even if it is 10 years old. If it is ACV, they will deduct 10 years of wear and tear, which can be as much as 40-50% of the roof’s value. So, if your roof is old, an RCV policy is more favorable, especially for major damage.
If the policy provides cover to modern standards, the insurance company may cover additional costs associated with upgrading roofs. This may include the use of environmentally friendly materials or improved drainage systems. In Chicago, there may be a roof insurance claim process for fire safety or energy efficiency improvements.
Example calculation:
Roof repair cost: $10000.
Upgrades are required to meet building codes: $3000 (e.g., new roofing or improved insulation system).
Renovation policy: the insurance company covers both the $10000 repair and the $3000 upgrade.
If you’ve had multiple insurance claims for roof replacement, this may indicate a high level of risk to the insurer. The likelihood of a new insurance denial or payout increases by 20-30% after the first claim. Two or more claims in the past – the likelihood of denial can increase to 50-70%. Insurance companies often consider the facts of claiming compensation and their period: after the third claim, the probability of unlucky can reach 80% if the claims relate to the same risk (e.g., few accidents or loss of property).
If your insurance claim for roof repair is denied, don’t give up. In many cases, the insurance company will allow you to have your case reconsidered. When a claim is not approved, you must submit a written appeal detailing the reasons why you believe the answer is unreasonable.
Suppose the insurance company rejects the file of a claim despite attempts to challenge the decision. In that case, you can appeal to an independent regulator, such as the Financial Ombudsman, who oversees the insurance industry. Contacting a state regulator in the role of the Illinois Department of Insurance (DOI) when there are violations by the insurer can end in sanctions for the company or a decision in favor of the homeowner’s file of an insurance claim.
If these avenues fail, you can file a lawsuit in court. Court costs with filing a claim can exceed the amount of compensation you may receive, so this step should only be taken in the most serious cases.
Contact your insurance company, invite an agent to document the storm damage, provide the documents, and wait for the results of the review.
Yes, filing a second claim increases the likelihood of your insurance rate rising, as insurers may see you as a higher risk.
A claim might not be approved due to lack of evidence, failure to comply with policy terms, or suspected insurance fraud.