Asphalt vs Architectural Shingles – Which Roof Should You Install in IL?
So, what is the difference between architectural shingles and regular shingles in Chicago, IL? Well, before installing a new roof, it’s really worthwhile for homeowners in Illinois to understand the difference between the two most popular types of roofing. To determine which option is more suitable for you, you need to learn more about what these materials are, as well as how they differ in the following parameters: life expectancy, strength, appearance, environmental friendliness, and of course, analyze the architectural vs asphalt shingles price.
Popular Roofing Choice in Chicago: Architectural vs Asphalt Shingles
Let’s first look at these two roofing options in Chicago’s neighborhoods to find out the difference between architectural shingles and asphalt shingles and choose the right roofing material.
Excellence is Our Culture
Asphalt Shingles Definition
Asphalt shingles are the most common roofing material in the community areas in the city of Chicago, covering approximately 75-85% of residential roofs. They consist of a fiberglass or organic material base covered with asphalt and protected by a special organic coating. They are also divided into additional subtypes.
Advantages:
- Low cost
- Ease of installation
- Wide range of colors and styles are available in Chicago
Disadvantages:
- Lower durability (15-30 years)
- Lower tensile strength and wind resistance
What Are Architectural Shingles?
Architectural shingles represent a higher-quality asphalt roofing option for homes in the Chicago area. They have a multi-layer construction that imitates the look of natural materials such as wood shingles or slate and provides higher durability and longer service life (25-30 years compared to 15-20 years for conventional asphalt). Architectural shingles also provide better resistance to climatic extremes and are available in a wide range of colors and designs. Although their cost is higher, they are a good option for homes in the Chicago Metropolitan Area. A roofing company close to me can help you select the best type for your home due to its durability and attractive appearance.
Advantages:
- High strength and durability (25-30 years or more)
- Better resistance to wind, hail, and other weather conditions
- Aesthetic appearance reminiscent of natural materials (wood, slate)
- Increased sound insulation
Disadvantages:
- Higher cost
- More complicated installation
Whether you need a simple repair or a complete replacement, our expert team in Chicago is here to help.
Architectural Roof Shingles vs. Asphalt Roofing – Full Analysis
Lifespan – Architectural Shingle vs Asphalt Shingle
Conventional asphalt shingles, which consist of three layers, will typically last 14 to 21 years for traditional suburban homes. Its service life can be reduced in case of extreme weather conditions or non-compliance with installation recommendations. Architectural shingles are more durable and have a lifespan of 24 to 30 years and in some cases up to 25-30 years in harsh climates such as Illinois.
Factors affecting the service life:
- climate;
- quality of installation;
- ventilation of the under-roof space;
- regular maintenance.
Architectural vs Asphalt Shingles Reviews About Durability
Architectural shingles surpass traditional asphalt shingles in durability due to their innovative multi-layer design, which integrates fiberglass, a robust asphalt layer, and safety granules of minerals. For homes in suburbs, this provides greater resistance to wind (up to 130 miles per hour) and hail. Traditional asphalt shingles are less resistant to weather conditions, like in Chicago, and can typically withstand winds of up to 60-80 miles per hour.
Architectural vs Asphalt Shingles Cost Comparison in Chicago
Traditional asphalt shingles initially cost less, around $1.55 to $5.55 per square foot, while architectural shingles are pricier, ranging from $4.10 to $7.55 per square foot. However, since architectural tiles last longer, it is more profitable. When we make repairs, we need to think about the future, don’t we? It’s a good idea to consult a roofing company close to me to help make the best decision for long-term durability.
Aesthetics Considerations – Architectural Shingles vs Regular Shingles
Architectural tiles offer a greater variety of designs, textures, and colors. They can imitate the look of expensive materials such as wood or slate. Their multi-layered structure creates volume and shadows, which makes the roof visually more attractive. At the same time, conventional asphalt shingles have a flat, monotonous surface that looks less aesthetically pleasing. For accurate pricing and to explore the best options for your roof, consider reaching out to roof estimating services near me.
Environmental Impact of Shingles
Both types of tiles have a certain impact on the environment:
- Asphalt shingles significantly increase the amount of construction waste because they do not decompose and can remain in landfills for hundreds of years. Meanwhile, contemporary shingles can be made from recycled products and reused for building highways. Architectural shingles contribute to less waste for homeowners searching for roofing repairs near me due to their longer service life.
- Architectural shingles contribute to less waste due to their longer service life. However, the production process of both types of tiles is energy-intensive and depends on petroleum products.
Availability and Market Trends
Here are some facts about the popularity and availability of these types of roofing:
- Both types – Widely available for sale.
- Market trends – Gradual transition to architectural tiles due to their aesthetic qualities, durability, and energy efficiency.
- Market dominance – Asphalt tiles still dominate the market, but the share of architectural tiles is growing.
- Market development – The roofing materials market continues to grow.
Explore our collection of informative and engaging videos on roof repair.
Architectural vs Asphalt Shingles Pros and Cons for New Roof
Conclusion – Asphalt vs Architectural Shingles
So, if the main goal is to stick to your budget – rather choose asphalt roofs. Comparing asphalt and architectural shingles, if you are more interested in fashion trends and the appearance of the property, architectural tiles are a better choice. They have a more three-dimensional look and traditional asphalt shingles come in a variety of colors and styles that mimic expensive materials like slate or wood shingles.
However, it is always wise to speak to local roofers near you to fully understand your particular requirements and the climate of the area you’re located. We are always here to help you with your choice, so don’t hesitate to contact us!
FAQ
What is the average cost difference between asphalt shingles and architectural shingles?
Architectural shingles will cost you more than asphalt shingles, and installation will be somewhat more difficult. But if we talk about the long-term perspective, architectural asphalt shingles will definitely win.
How do I determine which shingle type is best for my region's climate?
Can’t decide on the right roofing material? Well, contact a roofing contractor. A good roofing company will consider factors like rainfall, wind strength, changes in temperatures, and other climatic factors in your area.
Can architectural shingles be installed over existing asphalt shingles?
In some cases, architectural shingles can be installed over asphalt shingles, but there are certain limitations. P.S. It is advisable to seek advice from a professional who will be in a position to evaluate your roof and decide whether architectural shingles will be suitable for your case.
Which is more eco-friendly – asphalt or architectural shingles?
Both types of shingles have some environmental impact due to their production. However, because architectural shingles can last longer, they may reduce the frequency of roof replacements and the amount of waste. Thus, architectural shingles provide a more stable solution in the long run.
How often should architectural shingles be maintained compared to asphalt shingles?
Both of them are low maintenance and do not need much attention to be paid to during their lifetime. However, the architectural shingles offer more strength and durability meaning that the inspection and repair will be done after longer intervals. While asphalt shingles may need more regular attention, their affordability and availability make them a popular choice. But, architectural tiles can improve a home’s curb appeal.
