Cedar Shingle vs Asphalt Shingle Roofs: Comparison of Roofing Options for the Chicago Climate
Chicagoland homeowners often face a tough choice between cedar shingles vs asphalt shingles for their roofs. Each roofing option has features that can affect your budget, the look of your home, and how long the roof will last. Cedar tiles give a natural, rustic look and appeal to those who love classic styles, while asphalt shingles win points for cost and practical reasons. This article dives into all aspects so you can decide which best suits your needs.
Cost Comparison Between Cedar Shingles and Asphalt Shingles
The cedar shingle vs. asphalt shingle roof cost is a critical factor for residents of Illinois. Upfront expenses, long-term maintenance, and lifespan all play a part in the final tally. Below, we’ll break down these costs to help you see what fits your financial plan better.
Excellence is Our Culture
Initial Costs
Cedar tiles come with a higher initial price in Chicago than asphalt ones. Shingles range from $4.50 to $8.50 per square foot, while cedar shakes reach as high as $11 per square foot. For a 3,000-square-foot roof, total costs typically fall between $13,500 and $25,500 for shingles and up to $33,000 for shakes. If you’re wondering what is the difference between cedar shingles and cedar shakes, it lies in their appearance and thickness; shakes are thicker and more textured.
The cost of asphalt roof shingles varies from $1.50 to $5.50 per square foot depending on the type – whether 3-tab, architectural, or luxury shingles. Installing asphalt tiles on a 3,000-square-foot roof usually totals between $4,500 and $16,500.
Long-term Cost Considerations
Both roofing materials in Chicago have long-term costs beyond the initial installation. Maintenance and replacement expenses are factors to consider for a full cost picture.
Cedar roofs need regular care to keep them looking good and working well. For a 3,000-square-foot roof, cleaning every 2 to 4 years costs about $450 to $750 each time. Treatments for moisture and fire resistance add another $1,500 to $3,000 per treatment. Ignoring this issue can lead to higher repair costs in the future. Do you want to leave your roof problems “for tomorrow” or contact a roofing service company close to me?
Asphalt shingles require less frequent care but still have some costs. Yearly maintenance ranges from $100 to $300 for a 3,000-square-foot roof. Though cheaper in the long run than shake shingles, minor repairs may occur more often due to weather or wear.
Durability of Roofing Materials in IL: Shake Shingles vs Asphalt Shingles
Many cedar shingle vs. asphalt shingle roof reviews point out how vital durability is for Chicago homeowners. Each type has its durability strengths. Below is a look at how these materials hold up over time.
Critical Factors Affecting the Roofing Material Durability
Wood and asphalt shingles have specific characteristics that impact their longevity. Various factors can either extend or shorten the life of your roof, affecting its maintenance needs and overall performance. Experienced roofers near me know that external factors are sometimes more dangerous than internal ones. They can dramatically affect the cost of services and their duration.
These include:
- Moisture and weather conditions. Cedar wood shingles can suffer from moisture-related issues, requiring regular upkeep in wet climates to prevent mold, fungus, and moss growth. Asphalt shingles often fare better in such conditions but are still prone to granule loss from heavy rain.
- Installation quality. Proper roof installation in Chicago areas is crucial for both materials. Errors can lead to water intrusion and structural damage, reducing the roof’s lifespan.
- Maintenance requirements. Cedar demands frequent cleaning and treatments to combat moisture damage. Asphalt needs less upkeep but benefits from periodic inspections and debris removal.
- Insect resistance. Cedar is naturally insect-resistant but requires maintenance to deter moisture-attracted bugs. Asphalt generally resists insects without special treatment.
- Weather exposure. The best asphalt roof shingles are sensitive to extreme weather, such as high winds and UV radiation, which can make them brittle or cause them to crack. Cedar may age unevenly due to sun exposure but remains robust with proper care.
Whether you need a simple repair or a complete replacement, our expert team in Chicago is here to help.
Aesthetic Considerations Between Cedar and Asphalt Roofing Materials
The look of the roof significantly impacts the overall vibe of your home. The comparison of the cedar shake vs asphalt shingle reveals apparent differences in texture, color, and overall style impact. Below are considerations to help you choose which fits best.
Visual Differences Between Cedar and Asphalt Shingles
Wood shake shingles give Chicago suburbs homes a natural, rustic look. They come in warm colors like light amber and deep reddish-brown. Over time, these shingles become silvery-gray, adding an aged charm many find appealing.
If you compare asphalt shingle vs. tile roofs or any other material in terms of home appearance, asphalt tiles win with their versatility and wide range of colors and styles.
You can choose from simple strip shingles to luxury options like slate or wood. Popular colors include gray, copper, and black. Checking the cedar shingle vs. asphalt shingle roof pictures helps visualize these differences.
Impact on Curb Appeal and Property Value in Chicago Roofing
Cedar shake shingles shingles add a natural, charming look that makes homes stand out. Due to their premium feel, they can increase property value. A lot of buyers in Chicago areas enjoy the rustic and warm feel, possibly making them pay more.
When it comes to asphalt shingles, the versatility of design options helps homeowners match their new roof to their house style and create a cohesive look. While such shingles don’t carry the premium feel of cedar, asphalt’s affordability and clean appearance make it appealing to many buyers. Also, some luxury asphalt shingles look like cedar shakes; they often incorporate textures, colors, and patterns that closely resemble the look of real wood.
Environmental Impact: Comparing Sustainability Aspects Between Two Popular Roofing Materials
The ecological footprint of cedar and asphalt shingles is vital for eco-conscious Chicago homeowners. Factors such as resource use, energy production, and biodegradability all impact sustainability.
Cedar shingles are made from wood, a renewable resource. This makes them biodegradable once they reach the waste stage. Typically, roofing services in Chicago can leave the waste with customers upon request or send it to a recycling facility. Sure, it sounds like fun – a backyard barbecue with close friends celebrating a new roof or the completion of an old one.
In contrast, asphalt shingles are made from petroleum-based materials. Their production consumes significant amounts of energy and emits greenhouse gases. These shingles are not biodegradable, and once discarded, they fill landfills.
Asphalt shingles can be recycled into paving or other products, extending their life cycle. Cedar shingles and shingles may also require additional treatments, including chemicals to prevent rot or pests, which may affect their eco-friendliness. For more information on eco-friendly options, contact your local roofing service when you sign your contract.
Explore our collection of informative and engaging videos on roof repair.
Maintenance Requirements for Cedar and Asphalt Shingle Roofs
Maintenance affects how well your roof holds up over time. Cedar and asphalt shingles each need different care, which can impact your time and expenses. This section covers what you should expect when selecting between wood shingles vs asphalt shingles.
Maintenance Needs for Cedar Shingles
Wood shakes and shingles need regular care to maintain their natural beauty and long life. Clearing debris such as leaves and branches helps the shingles remain free of moisture, prevents decay, and keeps the wood in good shape.
Treatment is crucial. Applying wood oil every few years restores natural oils and reduces the risk of splitting. Wood oil with a UV shield maintains an even color tone, protecting cedar from sun damage.
Zinc or copper strips stop moss growth by reacting with rainwater. If you are thinking about checking your roof by contacting the roofing companies close to me, then do not worry – you have done everything right. Our professionals will help to detect minor problems before they transform into troubles.
Maintenance Demands of Asphalt Shingles
Roofers recommend that homeowners in the Chicago suburbs and Chicago areas should inspect their asphalt shingle roofs at least twice a year, preferably in the spring and fall. Inspections are also advisable after significant storms or heavy snowfalls. This approach allows for early detection of missing shingles, cracks, or granule loss.
Top roofing companies near me recommend cleaning your roofing system. This helps prevent the buildup of debris that can trap moisture and cause damage. Removing leaves and branches from the roof surface and gutters prevents water from becoming blocked, reducing the risk of leaks.
Choosing the Right Roofing Material Based on Location and Climate Conditions
Conclusion
Both cedar and asphalt shingles have pros and cons. The cost of cedar shake is more significant, and the material needs a lot of care, but it adds a natural, rustic charm that can boost home value. Asphalt is cheaper and easier to maintain, with many style options for various house designs. When setting a price, roofing services near you will focus on your budget, desired appearance, and individual preferences in finishing or materials. The customer must be willing to invest time in maintenance. You can also compare other materials, like metal roof vs asphalt shingle, to find the best fit for your home.
FAQ
What are the primary differences between cedar shingles and cedar shakes?
Shingles are thinner and more uniform. Shakes are thicker, rougher, and more rustic-looking due to their hand-split finish.
How does the climate in my region affect the choice between cedar and asphalt shingles?
In wet climates, cedar requires frequent treatments against moisture. Asphalt shingles might fare better but can degrade in extreme sun or heat.
What are the fire safety concerns associated with cedar shingles, and how can they be mitigated?
Cedar shingles are flammable; some areas restrict their use for this reason. Applying a fire-retardant treatment helps reduce risk.
Are there eco-friendly asphalt shingle options available?
Some asphalt shingles come from recycled materials; choosing these helps lessen your environmental footprint.
How does the resale value of a home differ with cedar shingles compared to asphalt shingles?
Homes with a cedar shake roof often sell at higher prices due to their premium look. The asphalt type of roof can still boost resale value if well-maintained and stylishly chosen.
What are the typical warranty terms for cedar and asphalt shingles?
When comparing cedar shingles vs asphalt shingles, the warranties differ. Cedar materials usually have warranties of 20-30 years. Asphalt tile warranties range from 10 to 30 years, depending on the type and quality.
How can I ensure proper maintenance of my cedar shingle roof to maximize its lifespan?
Regularly clear debris and treat shingles with wood oil to prevent splitting. Conduct professional inspections to catch and fix minor issues early.
Can I install cedar or asphalt shingles on my own, or should I hire a professional?
Installing either type of shingle demands expertise for durability. Hiring a professional helps avoid costly mistakes and guarantees proper installation.
What are the common signs that my roof needs to be replaced, regardless of the material?
Look for missing or cracked shingles, leaks, and sagging in the roof structure. The age beyond 30 years typically signals roof replacement time for most materials.
How do I choose the right roofing contractor for installing cedar or asphalt shingles?
Check their credentials, reviews, and past work in your area. Getting multiple quotes helps you find the best balance of cost and quality.
