Architectural Shingles vs Metal Roofing – Pros and Cons for Your Chicago Home
It is important to choose the right roof. It should be appropriate for your home style, climate, budget, and many other factors. So that’s why today we’re going to look at all the architectural shingles vs metal roof pros and cons. These two materials, available in Chicago, are now at the peak of popularity because of their durability and beauty. So, find out architectural shingles vs metal roof cost and much more about these roofing options, and choose the best one for your home in Chicago, IL!
Metal Roof vs Architectural Shingles – Key Differences Between Materials Options in Chicago
Well, to conduct a detailed analysis of standing seam metal roof vs architectural shingles, we will consider 6 main factors that distinguish these materials. Namely, we will talk about cost, durability, installation complexity, energy efficiency, and environmental friendliness. If you’re looking for advice or help with choosing the right material, a roofing company close to me can provide valuable insights and guidance.
Excellence is Our Culture
Chicago: Cost of Architectural Shingles vs Metal Roof
Ready to find out are metal roofs more expensive than architectural shingles in Chicago? Let’s start with the breakdown of the initial price. Architectural shingle roofs in Illinois typically cost between $4 and $6 per square foot, while metal roofs cost between $7 and $16 per square foot.
For a 2000 square-foot roof, that would be:
- Architectural shingles – $8,000 – $12,000
- Metal roofs – $14,000 – $32,000
However, metal roofs can provide significant savings in the long run in Chicago’s neighborhoods due to:
- Service life – Metal roofs last 40-70 years, while architectural shingles last 15-30 years.
- Energy efficiency – Metal roofs can reduce cooling costs by 10-25%.
- Maintenance – Metal roofs require less maintenance.
Durability – Do Metal Roofs Last Longer?
Metal roofs have a service life of 40-70 years, and some can last up to 100 years. They are weather-resistant, heat-resistant, wind-resistant, snow-resistant, and UV-resistant. They are also capable of withstanding fire, rotting, and insects. A Chicagoland roofing company can help you choose the best metal roof for your home.
The service life of architectural tiles is 22-30 years (sometimes up to 50). They have improved protection against wind and moisture compared to traditional roof tiles but may be less resistant to heavy hail.
Aesthetics of Architectural, Metal Shingles
Metal roofs are very stylish and trendy and come in a large number of styles, colors, and finishes. It looks like ordinary tiles or wood and can suit any architectural style.
Architectural shingles have a traditional look with an enhanced texture that can mimic wood or slate. A huge selection of colors and styles allows you to harmonize the roof with the architecture of traditional suburban homes.
Installation: Which Material is Easier to Install and Repair?
Architectural tiles are easier to install and do not require specialized skills or tools. Installation can be performed by most roofing contractors, which reduces labor costs. The average cost of installation (including materials) is $4.50-$7 per square foot.
What about metal roofs in Chicago and the suburbs? This installation is more complicated, requiring precise measurements, custom cutting of panels, and careful sealing to protect against local weather conditions. Due to the complexity, labor costs are higher, ranging from $750 to $1500 per 100 square feet. The installation process can take longer, depending on the size and complexity of the roof. It’s best to consult a roofing company close to me for accurate estimates and professional service.
Energy Efficiency of These Roofing Options
Metal roofs are very reflective of the sun and have low heat conductivity and this means that they do not overwork the air conditioning systems. Architectural roof tiles also possess their own energy-saving ability, get better insulated, and can also be made from materials that do not expand with heat. If you need assistance with roofing efficiency, consider searching for roofing repairs near me for expert advice and installation.
For maximum energy efficiency, a list with lighter colors is recommended with architectural shingles:
- gray;
- light brown;
- beige;
- bronze;
- light green, and others.
Environmental Impact – Metal Roofing vs Architectural Shingles
Metal roofs are fully recyclable at the end of their service life, which can exceed 50 years. Most of the metal roofs are made from up to 50% recycled content. This is an aspect of technology that preserves the utilization of new raw materials and thus, makes the metal roofs to be an environmentally friendly product. If you’re looking for comprehensive roof services near you, metal roofs are a great option for long-term sustainability.
Architectural shingles have a certain negative impact on the environment due to the complexity of their disposal. About 12 million tons of waste asphalt shingles are generated in the United States every year, and only a small portion is recycled. They can take up to 400 years to decompose in the ground and can also release harmful substances into groundwater.
Revive Your Roof, Revitalize Your Home!
Whether you need a simple repair or a complete replacement, our expert team in Chicago is here to help.
Which is Better Metal Roof or Architectural Shingles?
Explore our collection of informative and engaging videos on roof repair.
Conclusion
Consequently, architectural roofs have a shorter service life. However, it is worth considering the cost difference between architectural shingles vs metal roof. Metal roofs are more expensive and may not look as good as architectural shingles. So consider the initial cost and the long-term savings. Then decide a style that suits your preferences and the style of your home. It is recommended for homeowners to consult a roofing professional near me for more information and advice before making a decision for reroof. You can always contact us for a consultation and installation of a high-quality metal or architectural roof!
FAQ
What is the average lifespan of a metal roof compared to architectural shingles?
Steel roofs last much longer than architectural tiles. While tiles typically last 20-30 years, a metal roof can last from 40 to 70 years, or even longer.
Can I install a metal roof over existing shingles?
In some cases, this is possible, but there are certain limitations. It is worth consulting a local roofer, as installing a metal roof over an existing one may affect the weight of the structure and require additional preparatory work.
How do metal roofs handle extreme weather conditions like hail or heavy snow?
Metal roofs can withstand extreme weather conditions very well. They are durable, do not rot, and do not corrode. Metal easily repels water and snow and is also very resistant to hail.
What maintenance is required for metal roofs versus shingles?
Metal roofs require minimal maintenance. It is usually enough to periodically clean them of leaves and debris. Tiles, on the other hand, require periodic replacement of damaged elements and may require additional protection against moss and lichens.
Which roofing material is better suited for coastal areas with high salt exposure?
For coastal areas with high levels of salt, metal roofs are better suited. They are resistant to corrosion caused by salt and are not damaged by moisture. Metal roofs with a suitable coating can last a very long time even in aggressive marine conditions. Besides, architectural tiles will also be a good option compared to other materials. Both materials can also increase a home’s resale value.
