Which Is Better for Chicago Homes? Rubber Roof vs Metal Roofing
If you’re looking for a roof replacement in Chicago to make your home safe and dry, whether it’s commercial or residential, it’s important to choose your new roof wisely. In addition to asphalt shingles, rubber shingles, rubber roofing, and metal roofing are also popular. We will talk about them today, namely which of them is a durable roof and preferably a budget one. Which one is better than an asphalt shingle roof? Let’s take a look at what’s the difference between rubber roofs and standing seam metal roofing, and which is better for your case.
Rubber Shingles vs Metal Roofing – Roofing Material Composition
Before choosing a home’s roof, it’s worth considering what kind of materials they are. Let’s start with metal roofing options. They most often include steel, aluminum, and zinc. Steel roofs are the most resistant to corrosion because they are covered with a protective layer, so you can forget about corrosion. Metal roofs is the material that is strong, lightweight, and durable. These roofs also easily withstand strong winds and have a long service life.
Rubber roofs are a fairly new material, synthetic and durable, and are more suitable for commercial buildings (where there are large flat roofs). But rubber tiles are a super find for any home in Chicago. Manufacturers use up to 95% of recycled tires to make them. In addition, rubber tiles resemble expensive materials, are resistant to temperature extremes, withstand wind well, and are quite beautiful.
Excellence is Our Culture
Understanding the Difference in Durability
Characterizing emergencies in various Chicago Community Areas will facilitate the selection of the proper roofing type that suits every environment and structure.
The capacity of rubber and metal makes these types effective at handling Chicago Areas’ fluctuating weather that may affect the roof’s lifespan.
Whether you need a simple repair or a complete replacement, our expert team in Chicago is here to help.
Visual Appeal of Metal and Rubber Roofs
When choosing roofing materials, consider the specific needs of different Chicago Areas. The roof is not only protection from the weather but also an important component of the building’s appearance. So surely you would like to get a variety of colors?
Then let’s go over the basic facts about these materials.
So, rubber roofing:
- Rubber shingles can imitate traditional materials (wood, tiles).
- They are available in a variety of colors and styles.
- For commercial buildings in Chicago, dark colors are often used (there is a difference in energy efficiency).
- There are restrained natural colors and a palette of super bright ones.
- They can be painted or coated for additional customization.
Metal roof:
- Original and modern design.
- Also available in a variety of colors and styles.
- Can imitate other materials (wood, tiles).
- Suitable for various architectural styles.
The Chicago Metropolitan Area experiences diverse weather patterns, making it important for homeowners to select durable roofing materials.
Installation and Roof Slope Considerations
Homeowners in the Chicago suburbs often opt for metal roofs due to their durability and ability to withstand the area’s extreme weather conditions. Unfortunately, installing a metal roof can be more difficult than with other materials.
Here are the minimum roof pitch requirements for metal roofs:
- Raised seams – minimum pitch 1/4:12.
- Corrugated roofs – minimum pitch 1/2:12.
- Metal tiles – minimum pitch 3:12 or 4:12.
As with traditional shakes and shingles, the steeper the pitch, the better the performance and durability of the roof. However, you will definitely need professional roofing services.
Rubber tiles can be installed by almost all roofers. Moreover, they are suitable for a wide range of pitches, starting with a minimum of 3:12. In addition, rubber tiles are lightweight and flexible, easy to work with, and suitable for roofs with structural limitations.
Choose to install a rubber roof if you have a flat roof. You will get a quick installation due to the large rolls, which reduces the number of seams and possible leaks. However, it is important to ensure proper drainage, especially on completely flat roofs.
Lifespan and Weather Resistance in Chicago
An important factor when choosing a roof is its resistance to weather conditions. In Illinois, where the climate is diverse, this is especially true. So let’s compare:
So let’s compare:
- Rubber shingles – Resistant to extreme temperatures, rain, wind, and hail (class 4). Withstand winds up to 150 mph. Resistant to cracks, rot, and insects. The service life is up to 50 years.
- Metal roofs – Resistant to wind (up to 140 mph), snow, hail, and fire. Not prone to ice dams. Service life up to 50+ years.
- Rubber roofs – Also resistant to wind (up to 140 mph). Resistant to extreme temperatures and ultraviolet radiation. Service life is 20-30 years.
As you can see, all three roofing materials for residential homes demonstrate high weather resistance.
The roofing needs in the Chicago suburbs can vary, but as you can see, all three roofing materials for residential homes demonstrate high weather resistance.
Explore our collection of informative and engaging videos on roof repair.
Metal Roof vs Rubber Shingle Roof Cost Comparison
Rubber Shingles in Chicago
Materials for rubber shingles typically cost $4.25-$8.25 per square foot. So for a 1,500-square-foot roof, the total cost with installation is $12,000-$24,000. You will also need to spend approximately $75-400/year on maintenance.
If you’re looking for roofing contractors near me for the best solution, consider this type of shingle.
Rubber Roofing
Rubber roofing costs $4-$8 per square foot. For the same roof area, the total price with installation is $6,000-$18,000. However, in this case, you will need more frequent maintenance, 3-4 times a year to maintain the warranty. This will cost $100-450/year.
Metal Roofing
Metal roofing products are more expensive and their total cost is $8,000-$24,000. That is, the price per square foot of installation is $5-$20. But here you will get low maintenance costs, $75-$1,200 per year (taking into account that once every 20 years it will be necessary to paint the roof).
When looking for roofing installers near me, choose materials that can withstand the changing weather conditions in the area.
Environmental Impact
Rubber tiles and roofs are an environmentally friendly option that is made from old car tires. They are also durable and energy efficient (helping to reduce energy consumption). And at the end of their service life, they can be completely recycled – so you do not harm the environment in any way.
Metal roofing is also a very environmentally friendly choice. It can be completely recycled, and its long service life reduces the need for frequent replacement. In addition, a metal roof reflects sunlight. This can lower the temperature inside the building and reduce the energy consumption for air conditioning.
If you’re interested in working with qualified roofers near you, our team can help you select the right option for your home or business.
Other Factors: Metal Roof and Rubber Shingles Pros and Cons
In addition to all the above factors, let’s not forget about the nuances, because a roof is something we usually buy once in a lifetime. So here are the details:
Metal roofs:
- Metal roofs can be noisier when it rains or hails. But thanks to modern installation methods with insulation, the noise level can be the same as that of asphalt roofs.
- Metal roofs tend to reflect up to 70% of the sun’s heat, which helps reduce cooling costs by 10-25%. This is especially useful in warm climates.
Rubber tiles:
- Rubber roof tiles are much quieter when it rains, as they absorb sound vibrations well and provide peace of mind in the house.
- Rubber tiles have excellent thermal insulation. So you can easily maintain a constant temperature in the house and save on heating and cooling.
- Modern rubber roof tiles are usually odorless, and any odor disappears quickly after installation.
Several roofing options located close to me are tailored to handle citizens’ unique climate challenges.
Conclusion
So, which one better? As you have already understood, both rubber tiles and metal roofing systems are good options for a modern building (commercial and residential roofing). Rubber tiles are one of the most durable, and withstand extreme weather conditions, especially in IL. It also requires regular maintenance and sun protection. Rubber roofs last up to 50 years, require little maintenance, and are energy efficient, but have a limited choice of designs and can be prone to punctures. Metal roofs can last up to 70 years, reflect heat, and are fire-resistant and recyclable, but this type of roofing can be noisy in the rain, expensive to install, and easily damaged by large hailstones.
For those who are wondering about roof estimating services near me, many companies provide detailed quotes to help plan your roofing project effectively.
To make a choice, pay attention to your budget, roof pitch, design preferences, and the climatic conditions in your region. You can also always contact us for a professional free consultation. We hope we were helpful to you!
FAQ
What is the difference between rubber shingles and rubber roofing (EPDM, TPO)?
Rubber tiles are like small pieces of rubber that are put on the roof like shingles. And a rubber roof (EPDM or TPO) is a large roll of rubber that is rolled out and glued to the roof. That is, the shingles are individual elements, and the roof is a solid rubber sheet.
Are metal roofs noisier than rubber roofs?
For example, metal roofs are known because they can be noisier during rain or hail, especially if they are not additionally insulated. Rubber materials absorb sound better and are therefore quieter.
What kind of maintenance is required for metal roofs versus rubber shingles?
If you have a metal roof, periodically inspect it for damage and clean it of leaves and debris. Rubber shingles should be periodically cleaned of moss and lichen, and checked for cracks.
Which roofing material is better for areas prone to hail and storms?
Both metal and rubber roofs can withstand hail and strong winds. But it is important to choose the right quality material and install it correctly. Therefore, we do not advise you to save a lot of money and choose a do-it-yourself installation.
Can rubber shingles be used on flat roofs, or are they only for sloped roofs?
For example, rubber tiles can be used on roofs with a slight slope, but for flat roofs, rolled rubber materials (EPDM or TPO) are better suited, as they create a more airtight coating. And rubber tiles can be used for roofs with a large slope.
